Two replacement batteries won't recharge after initial charge. Ideas?

I replaced the battery in my ipad air 2 with a battery from amazon that had overall good reviews. I charged it to 100%, but it drained somewhat quickly from its first charge and then wouldn’t recharge a second time. Plugging in the cable would cause the screen to illuminate momentarily, so you would assume it was charging, but there was no charging icon on the battery icon.

I took out that battery and put in another one. Again, it charged to 100%, but drained fairly quickly and when it got to about 50%, I tried charging it and I got the same result…no charging icon.

Anyone run into this situation before? I did restore the ipad software after each battery replacement Thanks!