Will not sleep when closing lid

Question

MacBook Unibody A1278

13" aluminum unibody, 2.0 or 2.4 GHz Core 2 Duo processor.

574 Perguntas Visualizar todos

tjod @tjod

Rep: 359

12

10

1

Postado: 6 de jul de 2014

Opções

Will not sleep when closing lid

Hi;

The noted Macbook will sleep automatically per settings in System Preferences and when  > Sleep is selected. However, when the lid is closed it will not sleep and the back-lit Apple logo on the cover stays lit.

I've tried creating a new user - issue remains. Tried a clean install of Mavericks - issue remains.

This Macbook recently received a new screen (from iFixit) which in all other respects works fine, and there were no issues during installation.

Is this a hardware or software issue? Any pointers for further differential diagnosis are welcomed.

Thanks!

Respondido! Ver a resposta Também tenho esse problema

Esta é uma boa pergunta?

Sim Não

Pontuação 1

5 comentários

Did you replace the LCD alone or did you switch out the complete lid assembly?

6 de jul de 2014 por Dan

Dan;

I replaced the entire display assembly. I ordered here on iFixit, but noted that it had a screen glass labeled MacBook Pro rather than MacBook. My understanding is that they are the same internally

6 de jul de 2014 por tjod

Almost the same ;-} Still different enough. The MacBook & MacBook Pro have different locations in the lid that holds the lid magnet that tells the system when the lid is closed.

7 de jul de 2014 por Dan

That's interesting, and would certainly explain the behavior.

7 de jul de 2014 por tjod

This is really frustrating. I was trying to decide whether to replace the LCD or the display assembly. Given the difficulty of removing the glass, I decided to get the full assembly and practice with the glass on the old one when I could take more time with it.

It sure would be good of iFixit to send the *exact* part ordered or at least explain the differences if the exact replacement is not available.

7 de jul de 2014 por tjod

Adicionar um comentário

5 respostas

Solução escolhida

Peter Newman @pedro147

Rep: 113

5

1

Postado: 16 de ago de 2020

Opções

Thanks for the discussion guys. I just repaired a 820-3115 logic board that wasn’t recognising the battery (U7000 issue so it was replaced) and also the BIL unit was faulty so I left it disconnected. Then I noticed that it wasn’t going to sleep when I closed the lid and I have been told by a trustworthy tech (thanks Kike) that this Battery Indicator Light assembly also is a part of the sleep circuit so I will be replacing it tomorrow and will report back on my findings.

Esta resposta foi útil?

Sim Não

Pontuação 1

1 comentário:

Just to confirm my advice here. The BIL was faulty and replacing it allowed the machine to go to sleep when I closed the lid.

28 de nov de 2020 por Peter Newman

Adicionar um comentário

Did you replace the LCD alone or did you switch out the complete lid assembly? — Dan
Dan;

I replaced the entire display assembly. I ordered here on iFixit, but noted that it had a screen glass labeled MacBook Pro rather than MacBook. My understanding is that they are the same internally — tjod
Almost the same ;-} Still different enough. The MacBook & MacBook Pro have different locations in the lid that holds the lid magnet that tells the system when the lid is closed. — Dan
That's interesting, and would certainly explain the behavior. — tjod
This is really frustrating. I was trying to decide whether to replace the LCD or the display assembly. Given the difficulty of removing the glass, I decided to get the full assembly and practice with the glass on the old one when I could take more time with it.

It sure would be good of iFixit to send the *exact* part ordered or at least explain the differences if the exact replacement is not available. — tjod
Just to confirm my advice here. The BIL was faulty and replacing it allowed the machine to go to sleep when I closed the lid. — Peter Newman

Dan @danj Rep: 478,8 mil Self employed contract worker 35 329 970 · Answer 1 · 2014-07-07T04:40:20-07:00

Pergunta mais útil

Dan @danj

Rep: 478,8 mil

Self employed contract worker

35

329

970

Postado: 7 de jul de 2014

Opções

You'll need to locate the magnet in your your original assembly and then open up your new assembly and move the magnet to the correct location.

The easiest way to do this is using a metal washer and slide it along the edge of the frame that faces the keyboard. Then use some tape to mark the locations on the lid (both). To verify this is the issue get a rare earth magnet to emulate the lid magnet and slide it along the keyboard across the location you found the magnet in the lid the screen should go into sleep mode.

Follow this IFIXIT guide: MacBook Unibody Model A1278 Front Display Glass Replacement. Then move the magnet to the correct location.

Esta resposta foi útil?

Sim Não

Pontuação 2

1 comentário:

Thanks, Dan. I'll consider this after I've practiced with the glass in the original display assembly.

7 de jul de 2014 por tjod

Adicionar um comentário

Ben Eady @beneady Rep: 13 1 · Answer 2 · 2019-01-29T11:14:55-07:00

Ben Eady @beneady

Rep: 13

1

Postado: 29 de jan de 2019

Opções

Well I know this is a long time after the original post but incase someone else reads this – here's what I think it is and why. I believe the issue is with the battery indicator light connection or cable which is located to the right next to the battery connector on the motherboard. I can't confirm it just yet because I need a new battery light indicator unit after accidently snapping the cable connector whist putting my machine back together after replacing my keyboard. I suspect this indicator unit also functions as to tell the computer that the lid is closed (I'm guessing magnetically). So either the connector beside the battery on the motherboard is not attached properly or is damaged. I'll know for sure after replacing broken indicator unit.

Esta resposta foi útil?

Sim Não

Pontuação 1

1 comentário:

Both 13 & 15" use a hall sensor to sense the magnetic field of the magnet located in the lid.

The 15" model uses the same connection as the battery tester whereas the 13" uses the HD frame for its sensor.

29 de jan de 2019 por Dan

Adicionar um comentário

Waseem @waseem12378 Rep: 485 5 3 1 · Answer 3 · 2014-07-06T22:29:42-07:00

Waseem @waseem12378

Rep: 485

5

3

1

Postado: 6 de jul de 2014

Opções

Judging by what you have said, it seems like it's a hardware issue, the LCD assembly only contains magnets which trigger the sleep cable located with the HDD cable, to resolve this issue I would suggest a replacement of the Hard drive/ IR Sensor cable

Hope this helps

Esta resposta foi útil?

Sim Não

Pontuação 0

1 comentário:

Hi Waseem;

The hard drive cable is the same as it was originally - nothing changed except the display assembly.

7 de jul de 2014 por tjod

Adicionar um comentário

tjod @tjod Rep: 359 12 10 1 · Answer 4 · 2019-01-29T11:30:14-07:00

tjod @tjod

Rep: 359

12

10

1

Postado: 29 de jan de 2019

Opções

Hi All;

Thanks for all of the suggestions. Unfortunately, I no longer have that MacBook or the notes about it. I do know it was fixed, and went to a new happy owner.

Esta resposta foi útil?

Sim Não

Pontuação 0

Adicionar um comentário

MacBook Unibody A1278

Will not sleep when closing lid

5 respostas

Adicionar a sua resposta