As to protection I just got this in and think it would have provided enough protection if I had had it at the time I dropped my phone. I shattered the glass on mine as well. There is just enough plastic on the edges and corners (I think) to provide some shock resistence for the evo. Here is the amazon link: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B003ZHV6D0/ref=oss_product
It was one of the less expensive ones and does not bulk up the phone overly much.